I just completed a journey through the meta-narrative of the Bible through the lens of 9 “stories” or themes foundational to the Genesis story and consistent through to Revelation. This courtesy of Nancy Guthrie’s new book released just last month by Crossway, from whom I was able to receive a complimentary copy for review.
Even Better Than Eden by Nancy Guthrie is an accessible missional resource that is rich in storytelling and Reformed theology.
Guthrie’s work is a presentation of the gospel in a truly missional fashion: it is conversational and necessitates conversation; it is highly metaphorical and experiential; and though it is laden with heavy and unrelenting theological assertions, those assertions are expertly layered into a disarmingly vulnerable and empathetic offering.
The style of her writing is an accomplishment that would be readily accepted by the undecided, un-discipled, or estranged from faith. Her winsome approach to the Bible’s story as thematic rather than overtly theological is worshipful, and zooms out to an eternal perspective in a way that would foster great conversations on deep/hard/sensitive topics that might be otherwise difficult to broach in a church setting with a spiritually and experientially diverse group of people.
While Even Better Than Eden is written in prose that is whimsical enough to be enjoyed curled under a knit blanket with a cup of tea in the way of more frothy publications in the Spirituality/Self-Help/Christianity category for women today, it offers the benefit of true Biblical meat.
My one recommendation to the small group leader or discipleship mentor is to be aware that toward the end of the book Guthrie comes directly forward with a covenantal perspective on the Old Jerusalem where most of the book is a New Covenant Theology argument. This is obviously fine if you are of the Reformed/Calvinist tradition, but for small groups and discipleship pairs in Arminian/Wesleyan churches, a brief overview of the various covenant beliefs would be good to avoid confusion between doctrine taught from the pulpit and those explored in a study of this book.
Perhaps this theological conflict could be brought up amongst the study questions provided at the end of the book. Guthrie also provides great sources in her own appendices, providing: “Notes,” “Bibliography,” “General Index,” and “Scripture Index,” sections. She really does provide a framework for any discussion of disagreement on the book’s underlying theologies.
Here is another great resource to use for such a discussion. Written by John Piper, himself a doctrines of grace, Reformed theology subscriber, he however, does not adhere to any one covenant theology making him a good platform for an open exploration of a potentially divisive point of theology amongst denominations and traditions. Below is the link to an article where he simplistically compares the three main views on the structure of God’s relationship to man over the whole of Biblical narrative:
Overall on Even Better Than Eden: I greatly enjoyed the writing style and general argument of the book. I found it refreshing. While reading it, many of Guthrie’s insights caused me to experience not only a legitimate surge in my head knowledge of being loved by God, but also moments of genuine affection with the Lord.